Capo 5 - found this way a bit easier, for me at least :)
First tab as well so do be merciful, this is only an estimation!
[Intro]
C Am G F x2
[Verse]
C Am G
Darling, we're starting, she said
F
We go alive in a heartbeat
C Am G
Waiting for something in my car
F
A little hope out of nothing
Am
And through the hum on the line
[Chorus]
C G
She said I was a first time caller
F Am Em
But a long time listener
G D F
I've been waiting a while to talk to you
x2
[Verse]
C Am
Falling like trash from the sky
G F
I hit a patchwork of loneliness, crooked and wild
C Am
Hung from the stars and dropped through the night
G F
To a heatwave in hard placelessness, neon tiles
Am
And I got nothing but time
[Chorus]
C G
She said I was a first time caller
F Am Em
But a long time listener
G D F
I've been waiting a while to talk to you
x2
[Bridge]
Am C F
I want you to love me
C Dm
More than I love you
Am G Am
Tell me if that's something you can do
Repeat as they're singing 'First time caller, long time listener'
Enjoy!